I think the team did a fairly good presentation. Yvette did try to carry the show, and perhaps a bit less verbage might have been more helpful.
I do think the show was severely hampered by carrying only "off-battlefield" sites. There are, indeed, many sites in Gettysburg, including those on the show, that are worthy of coverage. Many of the areas of reported phenomena are within the actual National Military Park. Frankly, I doubt that the NPS would allow a show on the grounds, perhaps, rightfully so.
As to "voting off", I would welcome Yvette and the team back to Gettysburg. A follow-up on many of the discussion issues from the show (as witnessed on the discussion forums) may be enlightening.
Whether one liked or disliked (or, felt more strongly about) the show, the volume of message board traffic, both in threads and replies shows a wider interest than may have been expected. Perhaps before 2013, a follow-up might be in order. I hope that the show producers might incorporate much of the forum interests in such a subsequent show.
YES!!! she completely ruined the show for me, along with a few other things... but she was terrible. she should definately be taken off the show... or maybe the show should just be cancelled, just my personal opinion
She should, but the series is made by her and Karl's prodution co. They should at least get rid of Brian Shepherd and bring someone who knows where his/her arse is.